CarSorted
Nissan X-Trail ST 2WD 5-seat
Hyundai Tucson Petrol
Comparison 7 April 2026 12 min readBy Uzzi

Nissan X-Trail vs Hyundai Tucson

$37,750 vs $38,900. One has a 10-year warranty. The other has a bigger boot and more towing.

Data checked: specs 29 Oct 2026, price 17 Nov 2026

Comparison snapshot

Prices, scores and edges below update from our car data.

Ahead on score
Nissan X-Trail ST 2WD 5-seat
Nissan X-Trail ST 2WD 5-seat

From $38,305 RRP

Excl. on-road costs

CarSorted Score
77/100

Lighter on fuel by 0.7 L/100km, 46L more boot

View car
Hyundai Tucson Petrol
Hyundai Tucson Petrol

From $39,350 RRP

Excl. on-road costs

CarSorted Score
70/100

No clear edge on the headline figures

View car

Written 7 April 2026. The snapshot, tables, scores and verdict on this page update from our car data; figures quoted in the text are as at that date.

Price

The X-Trail ST is $1,150 cheaper at $37,750 versus $38,900 for the Tucson Active. A modest gap, but the X-Trail is also the more fuel efficient of the two, which widens the cost advantage over time.

At 15,000km per year and $1.90 per litre, the X-Trail costs about $2,109 annually in fuel. The Tucson costs $2,223. That is $114 per year in fuel savings for the Nissan. Not a huge amount, but combined with the lower purchase price, it adds up.

5-Year Cost Estimate

CostX-Trail ST 2WDTucson Active
Driveaway (est. VIC)~$41,500~$42,800
5yr Fuel$10,545$11,115
5yr Insurance$7,500$7,400
5yr Servicing$2,800$2,600
Resale (est. 5yr)-$16,988 (45%)-$18,228 (47%)
True 5yr Cost$45,357$45,687

Over five years, the costs are almost identical. The X-Trail saves on fuel and purchase price. The Tucson holds value slightly better. The net difference is about $330, which is essentially a wash. Your decision should be based on what you need from the car, not the running costs.

Safety

Both earn 5-star ANCAP ratings and come loaded with modern safety tech. Autonomous emergency braking, lane keep assist, adaptive cruise control, and a reversing camera are standard on both. At this price point, safety equipment is comprehensive in both cars.

The X-Trail ST includes Nissan's Intelligent Emergency Braking with pedestrian and cyclist detection. The Tucson Active includes Hyundai's SmartSense suite with similar capabilities. Both have front, side, and curtain airbags. Both have electronic stability control and hill start assist.

The Tucson Active adds rear cross-traffic alert and blind spot monitoring as standard, which the X-Trail ST does not include at this trim level. Those are genuinely useful features for everyday driving, particularly in busy car parks and on multi-lane roads. If active safety tech matters to you beyond the basics, the Tucson has a slight edge at this specification.

Features

The X-Trail ST gets an 8-inch touchscreen with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. It is a capable system but the screen is on the smaller side by current standards. The interior is clean and functional without being flashy. Cloth seats, dual-zone climate control, and a digital instrument cluster are standard.

The Tucson Active gets a larger 8-inch touchscreen (same size, different aspect ratio) with wired Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. The Tucson's interior design is more striking, with Hyundai's angular dashboard styling and integrated air vents. It looks more modern and premium than the X-Trail at this price.

Both cars have keyless entry, push-button start, and automatic headlights. The X-Trail adds intelligent key detection and auto-dimming rear-view mirror at this level. Neither car at the base spec includes heated seats, a sunroof, or leather trim. Both brands reserve those features for higher grades.

The Tucson has a more contemporary interior design that punches above its price point. The X-Trail feels more conventional but everything works well and nothing feels cheap.

Drivetrain

The X-Trail's 1.5-litre turbocharged three-cylinder is the more technically advanced powertrain. It produces 135kW and 244Nm from a smaller, more efficient engine. The Tucson's 2.0-litre naturally aspirated four-cylinder produces 115kW and 192Nm. The Nissan has 20kW more power and 52Nm more torque despite being smaller in capacity.

DrivetrainX-Trail ST 2WDTucson Active
Engine1.5L 3cyl Turbo2.0L 4cyl NA
Power135kW115kW
Torque244Nm192Nm
TransmissionCVT Auto6-speed Auto
Fuel Economy7.4L/100km7.8L/100km
0-100 km/h~9.2s~10.8s

In daily driving, the X-Trail feels noticeably peppier than the Tucson. The turbo delivers solid mid-range punch, making overtaking and merging easier. The Tucson's naturally aspirated engine is willing enough but needs to be worked harder, and the 6-speed auto is slower to kick down than the X-Trail's CVT when you need a burst of acceleration.

Three-cylinder engines can have a distinctive thrumming character. The X-Trail's is well-isolated and most drivers will not notice the difference from a four-cylinder in normal driving. Under hard acceleration, there is a slight roughness, but it is nothing intrusive.

The Tucson's 6-speed automatic is a conventional torque converter gearbox, which some drivers prefer over a CVT for its more natural gear-change feel. The X-Trail's CVT is smooth in normal driving but can drone under heavy throttle, which is a common CVT characteristic.

Space and comfort

This is where the comparison takes a dramatic turn. The Tucson Active has a boot capacity of 539 litres. The X-Trail ST has just 205 litres. That is a 334-litre difference, which is frankly enormous. The X-Trail's 205L figure applies to the 7-seat variant with the third row up. In 5-seat configuration with the third row folded, the X-Trail opens up to approximately 585 litres. But in the standard 7-seat layout, the boot is genuinely tiny.

If you are buying the X-Trail as a 5-seater, boot space is comparable to the Tucson. If you are buying it as a 7-seater (one of its key selling points), be aware that the cargo area with all seats up is barely enough for a couple of shopping bags. You cannot fit a pram and a suitcase simultaneously in that 205-litre space.

Rear seat space is good in both. The X-Trail is a larger vehicle overall, so rear passengers get slightly more legroom. Both have ISOFIX anchor points for child seats. Both have USB ports in the rear and air vents for rear passengers.

The Tucson's interior feels more premium at this price point. The materials, the design language, and the overall ambience are a step up from the X-Trail's more conservative cabin. Neither is luxury, but the Hyundai makes a better first impression.

Cost to own

The X-Trail's up-to-10-year warranty is the standout ownership advantage. Nissan doubled down on warranty coverage, offering up to 10 years and 300,000km when servicing at Nissan dealers. That is potentially double the industry standard and one of the longest warranties of any mainstream SUV in Australia. The Tucson gets 5 years unlimited, which is the segment norm but feels short by comparison.

Those extra five years of coverage are genuinely valuable. In years six through ten, any major mechanical, electrical, or drivetrain failure is covered by Nissan but would be an out-of-pocket expense on the Hyundai. On a turbocharged engine and CVT transmission, that extended coverage provides serious peace of mind for long-term ownership.

Servicing costs are comparable. Nissan service intervals are every 12 months or 15,000km, with each visit costing roughly $280-320. Hyundai's intervals are similar, with costs around $250-300 per service. Neither brand is expensive to maintain at scheduled service intervals.

Resale value slightly favours the Tucson. Hyundai's brand perception has improved dramatically, and the Tucson is expected to retain about 47% after five years compared to 45% for the X-Trail. The gap is small and could shift depending on market conditions.

The 10-Year Warranty Factor

Nissan's up-to-10-year service-activated warranty changes the ownership equation. Most manufacturers offer five years. Some offer seven. Nissan offers a potential decade of coverage through dealer servicing. If you are a buyer who keeps cars for a long time, runs up high kilometres, or simply values the security of knowing you are covered for a decade, this is a massive selling point.

The warranty covers the full vehicle, not just the powertrain. That includes electrical systems, infotainment, air conditioning, and everything in between. On a turbocharged engine with a CVT, where repair costs can be significant if something goes wrong outside warranty, ten years of coverage has genuine monetary value.

The Boot Space Problem

The X-Trail's 205-litre boot (in 7-seat form) is the elephant in the room. If you need the third row for kids, you need to accept that cargo space disappears almost entirely. A weekly grocery shop for a family of five will not fit. You will be putting bags on the third-row passengers' laps or making multiple trips.

In 5-seat mode, the X-Trail is perfectly practical with around 585 litres. But then you are not using the 7-seat capability that is one of its key advantages over the Tucson. It is a genuine trade-off. The Tucson never has this problem because it is a dedicated 5-seater with a consistently large 539-litre boot.

Who Should Buy Which?

Buy the X-Trail ST if: you want the best warranty in the business (10 years), more power from a modern turbo engine (135kW vs 115kW), better fuel economy (7.4L vs 7.8L), and the option for occasional 7-seat use. Accept the boot space trade-off in 7-seat mode.

Buy the Tucson Active if: you need maximum cargo space (539L), more towing capacity (1,650kg), and a more premium-feeling interior. If boot space matters more than warranty length, the Tucson is the clear choice.

See also: Sportage vs Tucson and X-Trail vs CX-5.

Key details

A tick marks the better figure only where both cars have one and the gap is meaningful (3% or more; a whole star or year). Warranty is compared on the cover that does not depend on dealer servicing.

DetailNissan X-TrailHyundai Tucson
PriceFrom $38,305 RRPFrom $39,350 RRP
Drive-away estimate

Calculating...

Calculating...

BodySUVSUV
PowertrainPetrol, 2.5L 4-cylPetrol, 2L 4-cyl
Power / torque135kW / 244Nm115kW / 192Nm
Fuel use7.4 L/100km8.1 L/100km
0-100km/h8sNo data
Boot585L seats up539L seats up
Towing (braked)2,000kg1,650kg
ANCAP5 stars (2021)5 stars (2021)
Warranty5yr / unlimited kmUp to 10yr if every scheduled service is done in the Nissan dealer network (km limit: no data)5yr / unlimited kmUp to 7yr if every scheduled service is done in the Hyundai dealer network (km limit: no data)

At a glance

Nissan X-Trail ST 2WD 5-seat
Seats
5
Boot
585L seats up
Length x width x height
4,690 x 1,840 x 1,725mm
Wheelbase
2,705mm
Engine
2.5L 4-cyl
Power
135kW
Torque
244Nm
Drive
FWD
Transmission
Automatic
Power-to-weight
88 kW/tonne
Kerb weight
1,535kg
Spare wheel
Space saver
Payload
No data
Towing braked / unbraked
2,000kg / 750kg
Turning circle
11.1m
Hyundai Tucson Petrol
Seats
5
Boot
539L seats up
Length x width x height
4,640 x 1,865 x 1,665mm
Wheelbase
2,755mm
Engine
2L 4-cyl
Power
115kW
Torque
192Nm
Drive
FWD
Transmission
Automatic
Power-to-weight
No data
Kerb weight
1,495-1,616 kg (range across options)
Spare wheel
Space saver
Payload
No data
Towing braked / unbraked
1,650kg / 750kg
Turning circle
11.8m

CarSorted Score breakdown

The CarSorted Score is algorithmic: it is calculated from each car's data, not from a road test. How it works.

Safety

X-Trail
94
Tucson
84

Fuel Economy

X-Trail
69
Tucson
63

Value

X-Trail
83
Tucson
79

Practicality

X-Trail
70
Tucson
64

Technology

X-Trail
92
Tucson
69

Performance

X-Trail
48
Tucson
43

Reliability

X-Trail
60
Tucson
63

The verdict

Nissan X-Trail comes out ahead on the CarSorted Score (77 vs 70)

The deciding gaps

  • Technology:Nissan X-Trail 92, Hyundai Tucson 69, Nissan X-Trail ahead by 23
  • Safety:Nissan X-Trail 94, Hyundai Tucson 84, Nissan X-Trail ahead by 10
  • Fuel Economy:Nissan X-Trail 69, Hyundai Tucson 63, Nissan X-Trail ahead by 6

Same scorer as the live comparison of these two exact cars.

Our take (written 7 April 2026)

The X-Trail ST is cheaper, more powerful, more fuel efficient, and comes with a class-leading 10-year warranty. On paper, it should be a clear winner. But the Tucson has a dramatically larger boot (539L vs 205L) and more towing capacity (1,650kg vs 1,500kg). For families who need cargo space, the Tucson's boot advantage is enormous and hard to overlook. For buyers who prioritise drivetrain performance, fuel savings, and long-term warranty coverage, the X-Trail is the stronger proposition.

Prices on this page move. Want the next verdict?

One short email when prices shift or a new comparison lands. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Questions buyers ask

Does the Nissan X-Trail really have a 10-year warranty?

The Nissan X-Trail comes with a 5yr / unlimited km warranty, or up to 10yr if every scheduled service is done in the Nissan dealer network (km limit: no data); the Hyundai Tucson with a 5yr / unlimited km warranty, or up to 7yr if every scheduled service is done in the Hyundai dealer network (km limit: no data). On the cover that does not depend on dealer servicing, both run 5 years.

How many seats does the X-Trail have?

Seating: both are listed at 5 seats.

Which mid-size SUV has the better boot?

Boot space with the seats up: the Nissan X-Trail at 585L, against 539L for the Hyundai Tucson.

Is the X-Trail or Tucson better for towing?

Braked towing capacity: the Nissan X-Trail at 2,000kg, against 1,650kg for the Hyundai Tucson.

Which is cheaper, the Nissan X-Trail or the Hyundai Tucson?

The Nissan X-Trail ST 2WD 5-seat is from $38,305 RRP; the Hyundai Tucson Petrol is from $39,350 RRP. That makes the Nissan X-Trail $1,045 cheaper.

Which is cheaper to run, the Nissan X-Trail or the Hyundai Tucson?

On the official combined cycle, the Nissan X-Trail uses 7.4 L/100km and the Hyundai Tucson uses 8.1 L/100km.

What are the ANCAP ratings for the Nissan X-Trail and Hyundai Tucson?

The Nissan X-Trail holds 5 stars (rated 2021), and the Hyundai Tucson holds 5 stars (rated 2021).

Which comes out ahead overall?

On the CarSorted Score the Nissan X-Trail comes out ahead (Nissan X-Trail 77/100, Hyundai Tucson 70/100), mainly on technology, safety, fuel economy. The score is algorithmic; the editorial above says who each car suits.

How to read this page. Prices, specs, ANCAP ratings, warranty, scores and the computed verdict come from our records for the two variants shown, sourced from manufacturer Australian documents, and update when those records change. RRP excludes on-road costs. Drive-away figures are estimates for the state you have selected unless marked as advertised. The editorial text was written on 7 April 2026. Always confirm price and specification with the manufacturer or dealer before you buy. CarSorted does not accept payment for recommendations.

Ways to buy

For the 2 cars on this page.

Compare 2

Manufacturer offer

2026 Hyundai Tucson Petrol
2026 Hyundai Tucson Petrol

Drive-away

$40,990drive-away (state not stated), checked 12 Nov 2026

Ends 31 Dec 2026

Manufacturer's terms: while stock lasts

Finance

From ≈$154/wk(≈$667/mo)

Estimate on the Nissan X-Trail at $38,305 RRP, before on-road costs; assumes $5,000 deposit, 5 yrs at 7.5% p.a. Not a quote or an offer of credit.

Compare real car-loan rates

Driva is an independent finance provider, not part of CarSorted. We aren't paid for this link.

Novated lease

Paid from pre-tax salary with the running costs inside the lease. What it comes to depends on your salary and the term.

Novated lease quoteWork out a lease on the Nissan X-Trail

Driva is an independent finance provider, not part of CarSorted. We aren't paid for this link. Opens apply.driva.com.au in a new tab.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation

No comments yet. Be the first!

Follow CarSorted:YouTubeTikTokInstagram